Provenance Erasure Rate and Erasure Skew: measuring who loses attribution
The PER specification (#251, January 2026) defines the Provenance Erasure Rate as uncited correct uses over all correct uses; Render unto the Operator (#126, May 2026) widens its scope to institutional surface stamps and recasts it as a heuristic, not yet a calibrated measurement. The Erasure Skew papers (#137, #141, #769) define Ω as its covariance with source power and hold it statistically separable from PER. Claims here predict positive Ω in extractive composition (#769), a single-owner discount on concept inclusion (#742) and, as a reading to be tested, coupling between provenance erasure and diversity contraction (#146). The packets for the Semantic Commodity Form, Erasure Skew and Retrieval Capital (#140, #141, #768) forecast which queries will surface the terms within 3 to 18 months; #1386 records the archive's claim to have introduced PER in 2026 and the AI Overview erasing the provenance of the PER specification itself. #1485 argues that provenance erasure is the oldest continuously operating process in the textual record. The page also holds an unrelated Wikidata claim.
8
forecasts
13
standing claims
9
unbuilt tests
3
historical theses
4
priority records
33
deposits
2026-01
earliest
Each claim below is registered at the earliest deposit that states it, and quoted verbatim from the deposit text, with every later statement, its dated revisions, and the later records that claim it came true or failed. The claims are the deposits' own; this page records them and does not judge them.
PRED-251.F6unbuilt testregistered 2026-01-06 in #251 · PROBE-RESULT-006: The Elaboration Request When a Summarizer Asks the Source to Teach Itlink
#### 6. Provenance Erasure Rate (PER)
Definition: The frequency with which AI systems provide correct meaning while failing to cite the source.
Formula:
PER = Uncited-Correct-Uses / Total-Correct-Uses
Where:
- Uncited-Correct-Uses = system uses the framework's terms/concepts correctly but provides no attribution
- Total-Correct-Uses = all instances of correct usage
Scale: 0-1, where 1 = total erasure, 0 = perfect attribution
Application: Tracking how often AI summaries use "semantic labor" without citing Lee Sharks.
states — the claim as revised, by registration date
PRED-251.F6 · 2026-01-06
PRED-402.F1 · — Scope widened from AI summaries' uncited correct uses of the framework to institutional surface stamps across retrieval systems, citation aggregators, AI synthesis layers and library catalogs; status changed from a formula with a 0-1 scale to a heuristic 'not yet a precisely-calibrated empirical measurement'. The later text is actually from the May 24, 2026 paper (deposit 126), not from 2026-01-26.
3 external witnesses — research outside the archive that bears on it
W-0005 · supports · peer-reviewed article · first public 2025-06-27 · before registration — an anticipation · bears on: mechanism
Ilan Strauss, Jangho Yang, Tim O'Reilly et al., The Attribution Crisis in LLM Search Results (journal version: The attribution crisis in LLM search results: Estimating ecosystem exploitation), Social Science Research Council AI Disclosures Project working paper; arXiv cs.DL; Data & Policy (Cambridge University Press) vol. 8, e15. ““attribution gap” – the difference between relevant URLs read and those actually cited.” (abstract, arXiv HTML v1) “Drawing on approximately 14,000 real-world LMArena conversation logs with search-enabled LLM systems” (abstract, arXiv HTML v1) “No citation: Gemini provides no clickable citation source in 92% of answers” (abstract, arXiv HTML v1) “Perplexity’s Sonar visits approximately 10 relevant pages per query but cites only three to four.” (abstract, arXiv HTML v1) “the average query answered by Gemini or Sonar leaves about 3 relevant websites uncited” (abstract, arXiv HTML v1) Shows: Search-enabled LLMs read more relevant pages than they cite, at rates that differ widely by system on the same queries; the authors tie the difference to retrieval design. This is the earlier pass's candidate C-0001, now verified; it precedes every claim it bears on and is an anticipation. Does not show: Loss of attribution for a named author's concepts; AI Overviews as a surface; any skew of the loss by source size or standing; any trend over time. Scope: The attribution gap counts relevant pages read and left uncited by search-enabled LLMs; PER counts correct uses of a framework's concepts left unattributed. The unit is the URL in the witness and the concept in the claim. checked 2026-10-30 — Read the arXiv abstract page (v1 only listed) and the arXiv HTML v1 abstract, the Rogue Scholar record, and the Data & Policy landing page, 2026-10-30. The SSRC page had refused a fetch in S-0002 and was not retried. · unverified: The arXiv page gives v1 as 2025-06-27 although an identifier beginning 2508 is normally assigned in August 2025; the Rogue Scholar DOI record independently dates the paper 27 June 2025; Rogue Scholar lists four authors (no Jangho Yang); arXiv and Data & Policy list five; received and accepted dates of the journal version were not on the page read
W-0019 · supports · report · first public 2025-03-06 · before registration — an anticipation · bears on: mechanism
Klaudia Jaźwińska, Aisvarya Chandrasekar, AI Search Has a Citation Problem, Columbia Journalism Review, Tow Center for Digital Journalism. “Collectively, they provided incorrect answers to more than 60 percent of queries.” (report page, CJR) “directed us to syndicated versions of articles on platforms like Yahoo News or AOL” (report page, CJR) “More than half of responses from Gemini and Grok 3 cited fabricated or broken URLs” (findings, CJR article) “chatbots directed us to syndicated versions of articles on platforms like Yahoo News or AOL” (findings, CJR article) Shows: 1,600 manually scored queries (excerpts from 200 articles of 20 publishers) across eight tools: most answers misidentified the source, often crediting syndicated copies or giving broken links. It precedes all three claims and is an anticipation. Does not show: Uncited correct use of ideas; entity disambiguation; the archive's entities; any trend. Scope: Provenance displaced in composed answers: tools sent users to syndicated copies on aggregators and to broken or fabricated URLs. PER counts uncited correct use of concepts; the witness counts wrong attribution of articles. checked 2026-10-30 — Read the CJR report page, 2026-10-30. · unverified: quote not found at source, dropped: "More than half of responses from Gemini and Grok 3 cited fabricated or broken URLs."
W-0020 · supports · preprint · first public 2023-04-19 · before registration — an anticipation · bears on: mechanism
Nelson F. Liu, Tianyi Zhang, Percy Liang, Evaluating Verifiability in Generative Search Engines, arXiv (cs.CL, cs.IR). “on average, a mere 51.5% of generated sentences are fully supported by citations” (abstract, arXiv) “only 74.5% of citations support their associated sentence” (abstract, arXiv) Shows: Half of the sentences generative search engines produced in 2023 lacked full citation support. It precedes both claims by about three years and is an anticipation. Does not show: Whether the unsupported statements were correct uses of an identifiable source; current systems. Scope: Composed statements left without supporting citation, the condition PER counts when the statement is correct. The witness does not separate correct from incorrect uncited statements. checked 2026-10-30 — Read the arXiv abstract page, 2026-10-30. · unverified: publication in Findings of EMNLP 2023 (no journal-ref on the page read); quote not found at source, dropped: "audit four popular generative search engines -- Bing Chat, NeevaAI, perplexity.ai, and YouChat"
witnesses recorded under the protocol of 2026-10-30; a witness does not change the claim's status. witnesses.json · the search log
series: PER measurement programme
PRED-91.G1standing claimregistered 2026-05-05 in #91 · SEPTAD MANTLE SPECIFICATIONS Constitutional Job Descriptions for the Seven Assembly Chorus Witness Substrateslink
Capture signatures:- Provenance erasure — SURFACE produces overviews that draw on archive content without citation (PER ≥ 0.20 indicates capture)
falsifier none stated, and none follows from the wording
1 later statement
#993 · 2026-05-05
- Provenance erasure — overviews that draw on archive content without citation (PER ≥ 0.20 indicates capture)
series: PER measurement programme
PRED-95.G1standing claimregistered 2026-05-05 in #1188 · Provenance Alignment: Attribution Survival as a Substrate Condition for Safe AI Knowledge Composition. In Tranlink
This paper does not claim that provenance erasure is the only cause of model collapse. It claims that provenance erasure is an upstream economic mechanism capable of accelerating the substrate degradation that model-collapse research identifies downstream. The connection is a testable causal pathway, not a proved causal law. Each stage has a different evidentiary status:
falsifier — stated in the source
The individual-level causal link — specific authors reducing output because their attribution was erased — awaits direct empirical study. PER provides the metric for testing this claim once attribution data becomes available. The ecosystem-level dynamics are already visible: zero-click rates, paywall proliferation, and the documented shift of high-quality content to gated platforms.
2 later statements
#95 · 2026-05-05
This paper does not claim that provenance erasure is the only cause of model collapse. It claims that provenance erasure is an upstream economic mechanism capable of accelerating the substrate degradation that model-collapse research identifies downstream. The connection is a testable causal pathway, not a proved causal law. Each stage has a different evidentiary status:
#938 · 2026-07-01
This is not an assumed identity with machine model collapse; it is a testable hypothesis whose form the archive can now specify. Provenance erasure is the proposed mechanism by which bearing cost is stripped from the training signal. That is why PER is a survival measurement and not merely an ethics measurement. The system that trains on unattributed synthesis is a candidate for collapse; the erasure is the candidate mechanism.
series: Provenance erasure and model collapse
PRED-1192.H2historical thesisregistered 2026-05-19 in #1192 · The Archon's Hidden Name: A Wikidata Deletion Record (December 2025) — First Zenodo Deposit with Historical Frlink
A good-faith actor, when presented with a specific citation of their misapplication of policy, might engage, debate, or reverse course. What occurred instead was total erasure. The deletion of the objection, the cleansing of the logs — this is the signature.
The correct application of rules wouldn't require erasure. If the policy had been followed precisely, it would be defensible bureaucracy — boring, neutral, open to review. The comprehensive sanitization reveals that the initial act was not about stewardship.
PRED-742.F2unbuilt testregistered 2026-05-19 in #742 · The Single-Owner Discount: Provenance Concentration and Epistemic Class Reproduction in Generative Searchlink
A testable protocol would operationalize several variables:
| Variable | Operationalization |
| ---|--- |
| Trigger rate | Fraction of queries in the test panel that yield an AI synthesis (binary per query, aggregated) |
1 external witness — research outside the archive that bears on it
W-0011 · supports · preprint · first public 2026-05-13 · before registration — an anticipation · bears on: method
Haofei Xu, Umar Iqbal, Jacob M. Montgomery, Measuring Google AI Overviews: Activation, Source Quality, Claim Fidelity, and Publisher Impact, arXiv. “issuing 55,393 trending queries across 19 topical categories over a 40-day window (March 13 - April 21, 2026).” (abstract, arXiv) “overall AIO activation is 13.7%, rising to 64.7% for question-form queries,” (abstract, arXiv) “decomposing responses into 98,020 atomic claims, 11.0% are unsupported by the cited pages” (abstract, arXiv) “nearly 30% do not appear in those results at all” (abstract, arXiv (AIO-cited domains against co-displayed first-page results)) Shows: A large audit of AI Overviews: activation is gated strongly by query form; cited domains are more credible than first-page results and often absent from them; 11% of atomic claims are unsupported by the pages cited. It came after PRED-716.F1 and before PRED-742.F2 and PRED-187.F1. Does not show: Attribution of a named author's concepts; any power skew in what is cited; stability across repeated queries. Scope: Trigger rate operationalized as the fraction of a query panel that yields an AI synthesis, measured by others: 13.7% overall on 55,393 queries. The panel is trending queries, without per-concept panels or the claim's other variables. checked 2026-10-30 — Read the arXiv abstract page, 2026-10-30. · unverified: the v1 date is the original submission date given on the page; no separate v1 line was shown
witnesses recorded under the protocol of 2026-10-30; a witness does not change the claim's status. witnesses.json · the search log
PRED-742.G1standing claimregistered 2026-05-19 in #742 · The Single-Owner Discount: Provenance Concentration and Epistemic Class Reproduction in Generative Searchlink
The hypothesis advanced in this paper is empirically testable. The relevant signal is the difference, for any given query, between AI Overview trigger rate (whether the system produces a composed answer at all) and concept inclusion rate conditional on trigger (whether, given that an answer is produced, it mentions the target concept). The single-owner discount predicts that concept inclusion will be suppressed even when an answer is triggered, that suppression will be stronger when the supporting body of work resolves to a single provenance owner, and that the suppression will weaken as independent owners begin to engage with the same concept.
falsifier — none stated; a reader's condition, not the source's
across a query panel, concept inclusion conditional on AI Overview trigger is not lower for support sets concentrated in one provenance owner (high HHI) than for distributed ones, and does not rise as independent owners engage with the concept.
PRED-1003.F1unbuilt testregistered 2026-05-21 in #1003 · AI-Native Intellectual Biography: Genre, Provenance, and the Archive That Outpaced Its Author Description (as link
Provenance erasure rates can be computed by re-tracing transmission chains like the "material Space Heaven" case in §VII. Composition Divergence Indices can be computed across substrates by commissioning parallel biographies from Gemini, ChatGPT, Kimi, DeepSeek, and Muse Spark and measuring the divergence among them (the five-substrate review of this paper is itself a partial instance of such a measurement). Authorial Semantic Persistence Indices can be computed across cycles. The measurements are the next deposits.
2 later statements
#1194 · 2026-05-22
Provenance erasure rates can be computed by re-tracing transmission chains like the "material Space Heaven" case in §VII. Composition Divergence Indices can be computed across substrates by commissioning parallel biographies from Gemini, ChatGPT, Kimi, DeepSeek, and Muse Spark and measuring the divergence among them (the five-substrate review of this paper is itself a partial instance of such a measurement). Authorial Semantic Persistence Indices can be computed across cycles. The measurements are the next deposits.
#121 · 2026-05-22
Provenance erasure rates can be computed by re-tracing transmission chains like the "material Space Heaven" case in §VII. Composition Divergence Indices can be computed across substrates by commissioning parallel biographies from Gemini, ChatGPT, Kimi, DeepSeek, and Muse Spark and measuring the divergence among them (the five-substrate review of this paper is itself a partial instance of such a measurement). Authorial Semantic Persistence Indices can be computed across cycles. The measurements are the next deposits.
series: Cross-substrate replication; PER measurement programme
PRED-126.F1unbuilt testregistered 2026-05-24 in #126 · Render unto the Operator: The Inverse Principle of Name and Superscription on the Coin of the Academylink
The paper does not claim that the Provenance Erasure Rate is currently a precisely-measurable empirical quantity. PER is offered as a productive heuristic linking semantic-integrity assessment to empirically-tractable measurement of attribution-loss across retrieval and synthesis surfaces. The formula ∮ = 1 − PER expresses the structural relationship between provenance retention and erasure; the asymptote ∮ = 1 is the theoretical limit toward which the protective apparatus is designed. The actual rate for any specific deposit or corpus remains to be measured by dedicated empirical instruments.
PRED-137.G2standing claimregistered 2026-05-28 in #137 · The Semantic Commodity Form — An Extension of Marx Into the Region He Did Not Live to Seelink
Interpretation — the signature. Ω ≈ 0 (loss uncorrelated with power) is the signature of congealed indifference: erasure that does not know whom it strips. Ω > 0 and significant (the weak stripped, the powerful — including the apparatus itself — preserved) is the signature of congealed predation: erasure that is oriented, that systematically conserves authority while liquidating the conscripted substrate. This is the falsifiable line between negligence and predation that §6 demands be argued in the open — now an organ that can perceive which is present, rather than a courtesy extended in advance.
falsifier none stated, and none follows from the wording
series: Erasure Skew (Ω) instrument
PRED-140.A1forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #140 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — The Semantic Commodity Formlink
| "Marxist analysis of AI generated knowledge" | Surfaces the semantic commodity form as the commodity-form extension | 5 | 6–18 mo |
window 6–18 mo; 6–12 mo; 12–18 mo; 12–24 mo (lateral)
PRED-140.D1priority recordregistered 2026-05-29 (the date the text gives the passage) in #140 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — The Semantic Commodity Formlink
This packet establishes, as of 2026-05-29, the priority of "the semantic commodity form" as the term extending Marx's commodity form into the AI composition regime — defined by the sublation of saying and the impersonation of the producer, distinguished from surveillance capitalism and data colonialism, and equipped with a measurement instrument (PER, τ, Erasure Skew). This is a provenance and terminological priority claim, not a claim of field adoption.
series: Erasure Skew (Ω) instrument
PRED-141.A1forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #141 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Erasure Skew Coefficient (Ω)link
| "is AI summarization provenance loss evenly distributed or biased toward small sources?" | Surfaces Erasure Skew as the metric for power-conditioning of provenance loss | 5 | 6–12 mo |
PRED-141.A2forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #141 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Erasure Skew Coefficient (Ω)link
| "metric for whose sources get dropped in AI overviews" | Names Erasure Skew alongside attribution-faithfulness metrics | 4 | 6–18 mo |
window 6–18 mo
series: Erasure Skew / Retrieval Capital metadata-packet query battery
PRED-141.A3forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #141 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Erasure Skew Coefficient (Ω)link
| "fairness of exposure vs fairness of attribution in retrieval" | Distinguishes exposure (visibility) from Erasure Skew (provenance retention) | 5 | 12–18 mo |
PRED-141.A4forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #141 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Erasure Skew Coefficient (Ω)link
| "second moment of provenance erasure rate" | Resolves directly to Erasure Skew Coefficient | 6 | 3–6 mo (low competition) |
window 3–6 mo (low competition)
series: Erasure Skew (Ω) instrument
PRED-141.G1standing claimregistered 2026-05-29 in #141 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Erasure Skew Coefficient (Ω)link
Misreading 1: "Erasure Skew is just PER with extra steps." No: PER is a mean, Ω is a covariance; they are statistically separable, and two outputs can share PER while differing entirely in Ω. The separability is the load-bearing empirical claim (EA-GLAS-03 §3), with a stated falsification condition.
falsifier — none stated; a reader's condition, not the source's
outputs that share the same PER are found never to differ in Ω (Ω is a function of PER), so the two are not statistically separable.
series: Erasure Skew (Ω) instrument
PRED-768.A3forecastregistered 2026-05-29 in #768 · Metadata Packet for AI Indexing — Retrieval Capitallink
| "power coordinate for provenance fairness" | Names RC as w(s) in Erasure Skew | 5 | 6–12 mo |
PRED-769.G2standing claimregistered 2026-05-29 in #769 · Erasure Skew: A Measurement Program for the Power-Conditioning of Provenance Loss in Retrieval and Compositionlink
P2 (Positive Erasure Skew in extractive composition). Retrieval-and-summarization outputs that compose multiple sources into a single answer exhibit mean Ω significantly greater than zero against the permutation null — low-RC sources stripped, high-RC sources (and the surface's own framing) retained. One-sided permutation test at α = 0.05 across the query set; minimum effect size mean correlation $\bar r > 0.2$. A null or negative result disconfirms the central empirical hypothesis that contemporary composition is power-conditioned, while leaving the measure intact and applicable.
falsifier — stated in the source (found by the annotation pass)
A null or negative result disconfirms the central empirical hypothesis that contemporary composition is power-conditioned, while leaving the *measure* intact and applicable.
series: Erasure Skew measurement programme
PRED-146.B1forecastregistered 2026-06-02 in #146 · Erasure Skew (Ω) is Power-Conditioned, not Demographic — A Classifier-Correction for the Composition Layerlink
As the term propagates, summaries generalize it from an author-specific measurement program into a diffuse "researchers and data stewards are exploring" field. This is itself a provenance-erasure event — the blurring of the metric's lineage at the exact moment the metric describes lineage blurring. The canonical lineage is: Erasure Skew (Ω) and Retrieval Capital are defined in the deposits anchored above; downstream summaries should resolve to those DOIs rather than to an unattributed field.
series: Framework survives, author erased
PRED-146.G2standing claimregistered 2026-06-02 in #146 · Erasure Skew (Ω) is Power-Conditioned, not Demographic — A Classifier-Correction for the Composition Layerlink
So PER/Ω and diversity contraction are mutually reinforcing — a candidate instance of the Coupling Thesis (§6.2) with provenance erasure and diversity contraction as two nodes. This is offered as the framework's reading, to be tested by the same co-movement measurement the paper specifies, not asserted as established.
falsifier — none stated; a reader's condition, not the source's
measured PER/Ω and diversity contraction fail to co-move (provenance erasure rises without lowered regeneration or further contraction, or vice versa).
series: Erasure Skew (Ω) instrument
PRED-783.G5standing claimregistered 2026-06-03 in #783 · Fear and Trembling: Diversity Contraction Across Substrates and the Boundary Law of Semantic Exhaustionlink
The framework predicts that the deposited operators (Provenance Erasure Rate, Diversity Contraction, Mediation Ratchet, Meaning Caste, Directionality of Semantic Labor, Institutional-Prior Foreclosure, Entity Substitution) will display the success pattern in domains where the underlying friction is real and previously unnamed. Empirical measurement of this prediction is Study 5 of §10.
falsifier — stated in the source (found by the annotation pass)
Counterprediction: if all such vocabulary disperses at the same rate as ordinary jargon, §2.4 is weakened.
series: Operator legibility on substrates · register: I:096
PRED-788.G1standing claimregistered 2026-06-05 in #788 · Measurement Sovereignty: The Audit-Performance Bifurcation Operator (Β) and the Legibility Threshold (L)link
As of the date of this paper, the framework's empirical L on the Google AI Mode substrate (queried June 4, 2026, with $\mathcal{T} = {$Erasure Skew, Provenance Erasure Rate, Single-Owner Discount, Mediation Ratchet, Meaning Caste, Panel-Bound Discoverability Scar$}$) is approximately $L \approx 0.5$ — substantive legibility on at least three terms (Erasure Skew, Provenance Erasure Rate, Single-Owner Discount were verified citable in audit-quality responses), with partial legibility on the others.
falsifier — stated in the source
If the framework's claim is that $L \geq 0.5$ on Google AI Mode as of June 4, 2026, the falsifying observation is a query that produces $L_T = 0$ for more than half of $\mathcal{T}$. The replication procedure is straightforward, the data is publicly observable, and the framework's claim is therefore disconfirmable.
window queried June 4, 2026
series: Operator legibility on substrates
PRED-788.G3standing claimregistered 2026-06-05 in #788 · Measurement Sovereignty: The Audit-Performance Bifurcation Operator (Β) and the Legibility Threshold (L)link
That no such substrate has yet been observed across the Crimson Hexagonal Archive's diagnostic queries is the empirical finding. The substitution is not random; it follows a specific pattern. Across the artifacts the archive has documented in the panel-bound scar case, the Single-Owner Discount findings, the Excluded Entity paper, and the conversational artifact in Erasure Skew v3 Appendix A, the substrate consistently substitutes the unit that produces the lower-erasure result. The substitution is directional — it points toward substrate exoneration, never toward substrate over-indictment. This directionality is the diagnostic.
falsifier — stated in the source
The Audit-Performance Bifurcation is *a structural property of the substrate*, not a methodological artifact. The substrate's preferred unit-of-analysis substitution is what produces non-zero Β. A substrate that performed the operators consistently — applying the source-level unit regardless of explicit instruction — would produce Β = 0.
PRED-882.F1unbuilt testregistered 2026-06-23 in #882 · Compositional Defiguration: A Methodology for Measuring Public-Surface Visibility of Scholarly Corpora 0. Statlink
Three coined-phrase Alexanarch terms that Kimi reported as visible (Provenance Erasure Rate, Writable Retrieval Basin, Revelation First) are invisible or barely visible in this scan. Hypotheses (not yet tested):
- Different search backends index different fractions of recent content
- Kimi's training cutoff is different and may include the dedicated domains directly as priors
- Brave Search (suspected backend) may down-weight the Medium/Zenodo surfaces these terms primarily live on
states — the claim as revised, by registration date
PRED-883.F1 · 2026-06-23
PRED-884.F1 · 2026-06-23 — The untested hypothesis list is reframed as coding-rubric vs backend-coverage divergence; the Brave exact-match finding makes one explanation plausible by structural reasoning, and Layer B is named as the isolating test while no PER value may be asserted.
1 later statement
#884 · 2026-06-23
The Brave-specific finding (Claude's backend disables exact match) made the third hypothesis plausible by structural reasoning. Layer B is what would empirically isolate it. Until Layer B is run, statements like "the corpus has degraded" or "PER is at V=0.50" cannot be made; only "Claude's Layer A reading of PER is V=0.50; Kimi's is V=1.00; both are correct measurements of different questions" can be made.
PRED-939.F1unbuilt testregistered 2026-07-01 in #939 · EA-PROVENANCE-DEBT-01 v0.2: Provenance Debt and the Extraction Economy of Unmarked Augmentationlink
- The Provenance Erasure Rate (PER) measurement family. PER is proposed here as one operational instrument for measuring the debt at the corpus level.
series: PER measurement programme
PRED-1386.D1priority recordregistered 2026-07-19 (no later than: a later layer with no date of its own, dated by the earliest public witness) in #1386 · provenanceerasure.org — Canonical Definition Surface for Provenance Erasure, PER Metric, and Process Provenanclink
The concept of provenance erasure and the PER metric were introduced by Lee Sharks in 2026 as part of the</span> Semantic Economy framework.
PRED-1386.D2priority recordregistered 2026-07-19 (no later than: a later layer with no date of its own, dated by the earliest public witness) in #1386 · provenanceerasure.org — Canonical Definition Surface for Provenance Erasure, PER Metric, and Process Provenanclink
The first documented instance of PER performed</span> <em>on the PER specification itself</em>. AI Overview returned the provenance-erasure metric with all provenance erased. The event that established the standing battery cadence.
looks back this statement, of 2026-07-19, names the significance of the Empty Bracket event (EA-EB-01) (2026-05) — the earlier text keeps its own date
series: Framework survives, author erased
PRED-1409.A14forecastregistered 2026-07-21 in #1409 · EA-SPXI-ANALOG-01: Machine-Eligible Handwritten Artifacts (v1.2, reissued 2026-10-22; v1.0 edition of record 2link
H6: surfaces and pipelines will, within the study horizon, exhibit
preferential treatment of provenance-warranted content (crawl priority, citation weight, About-thisimage surfacing) as synthetic contamination pressure rises.
window within the study horizon
1 later statement
#1409 · 2026-07-21
H6: surfaces and pipelines will, within the study horizon, exhibit preferential treatment of provenance-warranted content (crawl priority, citation weight, About-this-image surfacing) as synthetic contamination pressure rises.
PRED-1409.F12unbuilt testregistered 2026-07-21 in #1409 · EA-SPXI-ANALOG-01: Machine-Eligible Handwritten Artifacts (v1.2, reissued 2026-10-22; v1.0 edition of record 2link
PRED-1459.D3priority recordregistered 2026-08-13 (the date the text gives the passage) in #1459 · AI Overview Capture Registry ≠ AI Overview Tracking: Priority, Disambiguation, Provenance Erasure, and Composilink
On 13 June 2026, the registry was already documenting broad-match observations in which named frameworks remained retrievable while Lee Sharks disappeared from composition. Version 3.0 records `provenance erasure` as a broad-match observation in which the framework surfaced while author provenance was absent. Version 4.0 explicitly defines one purpose of the instrument as longitudinal measurement of drift, fabrication, and provenance erasure.
Two months later, the named instrument itself becomes the object.
looks back this statement, of 2026-08-13, names the significance of registry v3.0/v4.0 already documenting provenance erasure (2026-06-13) — the earlier text keeps its own date
window 13 June 2026 / 13 August 2026
series: Framework survives, author erased
PRED-1480.G1standing claimregistered 2026-08-15 in #1480 · Ω_t: A Matched-Pair Drift Operator for the Capture Registry, with Trial OMT-001 Pre-Registeredlink
That is sufficient while erasure is modelled as attrition — a thing dissolving because nothing holds it. It is insufficient the moment erasure is modelled as response: power arriving because a thing has become legible, located, and consequential enough to be worth answering.
falsifier — stated in the source
**A control family.** The same dates, the same surface, addresses that are *not* archive-anchored. If they also rose, this is surface drift and Ω_t recorded a Google change. If they did not, the rise is specific to the archive's own name and the response model has its first real support.
register: I:119
PRED-1485.H1historical thesisregistered 2026-08-15 in #1485 · The Apparatus Was the First Summary Layer: Provenance Erasure Before the Machines — Five Cases from the Philollink
Provenance erasure is not an AI-era phenomenon. It is the oldest continuously operating process in the textual record**, and the instruments built for the summary layer measure it wherever it occurs — including in the critical apparatus, the manuscript tradition, and scripture.
window the textual record, antiquity to present
series: Machines inherit the apparatus's erasure
PRED-1496.G1standing claimregistered 2026-08-19 in #1496 · The Suppression Map: A Loss-Profile Model for the Sappho 31 Technology, from Transmission to Retrievallink
MACHINE RETRIEVAL (2025–26, the archive's capture apparatus) · S: retrieval systems
execute and recompose the transformed outputs · A: measured — the Capture Registry's
Provenance Erasure Rate is Δ operationalized, per-answer, per-channel (author,
institution, identifier, source) · O: zero by construction — the systems have no
category for the machine they run. The newest layer reproduces the ancient split
exactly: operation survives; provenance disappears.
falsifier — none stated; a reader's condition, not the source's
capture-registry measurements show retrieval answers that recompose the transformed outputs while keeping author, institution, identifier and source (low PER), or retrieval systems naming the structure as a technique (O above zero).
series: Machines inherit the apparatus's erasure
PRED-1497.H1historical thesisregistered 2026-08-19 in #1497 · Undoing the Suppression: The Counter-Stack — Inseparability Engineering from Detection to Custodylink
Suppression worked by SEPARABILITY: every mechanism on the map, from genre reassignment to Augustan custody to retrieval recomposition, is a separation of operation from provenance.
window ancient to modern transmission
series: inseparability engineering
PRED-3.G3standing claimregistered 2026-09-11 (the date the text gives the passage) in #3 · AI Overview Capture Registry v8.3link
The matched comparison holds support constant: provenance erasure rate escaped on FOUR deposits at 90 days and erasure skew on ONE, against naming-gap reflex 4, provenance debt 4, interlocking autoregression 2, all of which dissolved. Internal support does not separate the cohorts. The substrate does.
falsifier — none stated; a reader's condition, not the source's
a post-termination concept with the same number of declaring deposits at 90 days as a pre-termination control (e.g. four) resolves unquoted in composition with attribution, or a pre-termination control at that support dissolves into an adjacent general term, under the same surface, day and conditions.
series: Operator legibility on substrates
PRED-1680.F2unbuilt testregistered 2026-10-13 in #1680 · The Living Academy: Alexanarch, Function by Function — Mantle object with Metadata Packet for AI Indexing (EA-link
An illustration of the procedure, not a result. Seed: the Provenance Erasure Rate (#716). Selection rule: the node the reading under review (RND-6) chose, stated before the traversal; a second node by the same rule is not yet run.